Costuming for Nerds, Part 21
Nov. 15th, 2023 02:32 pmHey, Halloween happened recently, didn't it? There was a certain poignancy in the first year with our daughter off at college so it was just the four of us. We did pull off some pretty cool costumes, though.
There's always that balance of Mark wanting to do a striking, scary monster costume that impresses his students at work, while also having a couples theme we can do together. This year we finally decided on the Witch-King and Eowyn.

Mark tried a few effects with makeup, particular a glow-in-the-dark kind that was only partially effective, but the best component ended up being a skeletal crown with a cobewebby veil. We were both able to repurpose some parts like the black robes and the shield (re-painted). I got a tunic-y dress and leggings at the thrift store, and I knitted the chain mail with metallic-ish yarn. I'd done something similar before for my Freya costume, but I wasn't quite satisfied with the look, so I tried something a little more intricate. It was far more work than I anticipated, but the effect was quite good.


Absolutely no one had any idea who I was. A few people recognized Eowyn once I reminded them of her character's connection with the Witch-King. But it took a lot of explaining. So we're still stuck with the question: ultra-geeky costumes, or more bland ones that everyone knows right away?
Luke's costume was easy, reusing the wizard costume for Gandalf. Ryan's was mostly composed of thrift items, as well as toe socks that we painted and stuffed for his short hobbit legs. He was fully committed, kneeling at people's doors for trick-or-treating (until the legs fell off, because we didn't really devise a great way to attach them).

And everyone kept thinking Ryan was from Harry Potter. Excuse me. Excuse me. Did they not notice the excruciating details of the One Ring and the leaf brooch??

No, of course not. All they saw was a kid in glasses (because Ryan needs them to see) and a cloak and made a lazy assessment. Sigh. They were great costumes anyway.
There's always that balance of Mark wanting to do a striking, scary monster costume that impresses his students at work, while also having a couples theme we can do together. This year we finally decided on the Witch-King and Eowyn.

Mark tried a few effects with makeup, particular a glow-in-the-dark kind that was only partially effective, but the best component ended up being a skeletal crown with a cobewebby veil. We were both able to repurpose some parts like the black robes and the shield (re-painted). I got a tunic-y dress and leggings at the thrift store, and I knitted the chain mail with metallic-ish yarn. I'd done something similar before for my Freya costume, but I wasn't quite satisfied with the look, so I tried something a little more intricate. It was far more work than I anticipated, but the effect was quite good.


Absolutely no one had any idea who I was. A few people recognized Eowyn once I reminded them of her character's connection with the Witch-King. But it took a lot of explaining. So we're still stuck with the question: ultra-geeky costumes, or more bland ones that everyone knows right away?
Luke's costume was easy, reusing the wizard costume for Gandalf. Ryan's was mostly composed of thrift items, as well as toe socks that we painted and stuffed for his short hobbit legs. He was fully committed, kneeling at people's doors for trick-or-treating (until the legs fell off, because we didn't really devise a great way to attach them).

And everyone kept thinking Ryan was from Harry Potter. Excuse me. Excuse me. Did they not notice the excruciating details of the One Ring and the leaf brooch??

No, of course not. All they saw was a kid in glasses (because Ryan needs them to see) and a cloak and made a lazy assessment. Sigh. They were great costumes anyway.